IMG_4071

I managed to pick up an iPhone 5s yesterday and have been trying out its new features and enhancements. Here’s my review of the device after using it for 24 hours…

Design: As the name implies, the iPhone 5s is based directly on the design of the iPhone 5. It has the same shiny edges, metal back with glass top and bottom caps, and front that is dominated by the display. The only tell-tale signs that the 5s is not a 5 are the slightly tweaked Home button design, larger rear camera flash, and if you opt for one of the two new color options.

I chose the Space Gray version. Yes, I did not have much of a choice given the extreme constraints to the silver and gold options, but Space Gray is what I would have picked regardless. Why is it called Space Gray? Only Apple could answer that, but If I was in charge, I would have named it “Dark Silver.” The color is more in-line with the silver metal on the white model, but it is noticeably darker.

I’d say that the gray is akin to the metal band around the iPhone 4 and 4S, making me think of the Space Gray iPhone 5s design as being the best of both the iPhone 4 and iPhone 5. I really do enjoy the Space Gray model, and, from an aesthetics perspective, think it is much nicer than the black/slate iPhone 5 (which I carried previously).

5s (left), 5 (right)

5s (left), 5 (right)

In comparison to the iPhone 5′s black glass on the front and back, I think the 5s’s glass is slightly darker/less transparent, but this could just be my perspective.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The phone feels just as solid, thin, and light as the iPhone 5, so no shock in heft for customers coming off of an iPhone 5. But for those coming from an iPhone 4/4s or earlier, this design is a leap forward in construction and feel.

IMG_4056

The leather case: To go with the iPhone, I purchased one of Apple’s new iPhone 5s leather cases. While in line, Apple employees passed around the new case in every color, and the stores seemed to have had ample supplies of the new accessory. Had this story been written about an iPhone launch in year’s past, I don’t think I would have been able to say that. I chose the black leather case to match the phone’s color, but I think the beige and Product RED versions are also impressive.

The case looks and smells like leather, but it does not have much heft or thickness to it. In fact, a Twitter user compared the feel of the case to an egg carton, and I would agree with that. The leather is definitely a different feel from the material used for the iPad Smart Covers. I do very much enjoy the case, though. It’s thin, light, and its design matches the phone well. I don’t normally use cases, but I think I am going to keep this one.

photo

I also purchased the iPhone 5s dock, but the case does not fit in it. For a company that prides itself on completely integrated solutions, this is surprising to me, but not a true flaw. Removing the phone from the case is not difficult, but it requires effort.

I do recommend the case, but I think it is slightly overpriced at $39. The $10 difference between the leather case and the silicone iPhone 5c case makes sense, but perhaps the pricing should have been $19 and $29, respectively.

Battery life: I haven’t conducted extensive battery testing for the iPhone 5s, but I can say that it has slightly exceeded my expectations. I’ve been using the phone moderately (tweeting, texting, some web browsing, email, and a half-dozen or so phone calls) today, and I am at just under 70% battery life. Based on what I remember about my iPhone 5, this is solid battery performance. Of course, this could change as the battery continues to calibrate, and I did attempt to calibrate my battery yesterday by running it down to 0% and charging it up fully.

Performance: The iPhone 5s, so far, does not feel much snappier than the iPhone 5. This is not exactly a negative thing; the iPhone 5′s system speed is already fantastic. Moving around the operating system and launching apps mostly feels the same on the 5s as with the 5. I’ve done some unscientific measurements by launching the same apps simultaneously on both devices, but the results are always close.

For those coming from an iPhone 5, the speed increase will not be very noticeable for minor tasks. I remember when I upgraded from an iPhone 3G to iPhone 3GS, the speed increases were certainly visible to me throughout the system. Moving from the iPhone 5 to iPhone 5s does not take the same leap in my usage. However, those upgrading from anything below an iPhone 5 will be delighted. The speed difference between my A5-based iPad on iOS 7 and this iPhone 5s are night and day.

The new speed is slightly visible in terms of animations. For example, swiping through Home screens on the 5s feels ever-so-slightly smoother than on the 5. Moving between camera modes on the iPhone 5s is noticeably quicker than on the 5, and even swiping down to access system-search on the 5s’s Home screen is smoother than on the 5. Similarly smoother is swiping down the transparent Notification Center panel.

Another unscientific speed test I often like to test with phones is the speed of rotating an app interface. For example, rotating the Music app from portrait to landscape opens up a new “Album Wall” view, and changing the orientation of the Calculator app moves between a simple interface and a Scientific Calculator mode. So far, I’ve felt no difference here between the new phones.

I have also tested the speed of turning off and turning on the phones. The speed of booting down has been consistently the same, but booting up the device has been approximately 2-3 seconds quicker on the 5s. Both of these phones are running mostly the same content.

Another place where you will find a difference is in booting up graphically-heavy games. Games seem to load more quickly for me, but I have not fully tested gameplay in titles such as the new Infinity Blade.

I feel as if the iPhone 5s would seem even faster than the iPhone 5 if it were not for some of iOS 7′s lengthy animations. Animations that deal with length are mostly present with launching apps, closing apps, and unlocking the phone. Apple should decrease this glitz.

IMG_4059

Speaker: With phones that play media like games, music, and video, the audio quality is important. The iPhone 5′s speaker sounds solid, and the 5s’s speaker sounds seems to have equal performance. An App Store decibel meter tells me that the 5s is literally a couple to a few decibels louder than the 5, but this is unscientific, casual testing.

IMG_4066

Camera: I haven’t used or compared the camera much, but the speed of taking photos is clearly quicker on the 5s. Burst Mode works well and the user-interface for navigating between your several shots is simple.

Likewise with slow-motion mode, taking 120 frames-per-second video is fun, and the system for choosing which parts if your shot that you want to be slowed down is simple to use. A couple people tell me that they have had trouble playing back the slow-motion video via AirPlay on an Apple TV, but the results are not consistent.

The new True Tone dual-LED flash has made for noticeably better night-time photos. Control Center’s flashlight feature only lights up the top bulb, but I don’t consider this a flaw, just something I was curious about.

IMG_4067

Touch ID: Unless you’re a camera enthusiast, Touch ID is the reason to upgrade from an iPhone 5. Of course, those coming from a non-iPhone or an iPhone older than the iPhone 5 will have plenty more to find new. Touch ID is simple to setup. Either during the iPhone’s setup process or in Settings, the iPhone can register your fingerprint. In the iPhone’s main setup mode, the process primarily focuses on registering one finger, but you can add up to five. I found the setup process simple to follow, and it took less than a minute for a single finger. Apple definitely nailed it with the setup software.

The hardware aspect of Touch ID has been terrific for me thus far. The system has recognized my assigned fingerprints nearly every time I have gone to unlock my phone. It is noticeably quicker than entering a four-digit PIN. My muscle memory is yet to fully adjust to not sliding to unlock, but I’m sure it will get there soon. I think Apple should make the slide to unlock screen less prominent on the 5s, but it is still (obviously) important to keep around. Unlocking the phone with my fingerprint has been a joy so far, and the hardware seems to be out of a different universe from fingerprint scanners that I have used on other devices. We’ll have to see, though, how that holds up after months of use.

While unlocking the phone has been mostly perfect, the general Touch ID system is not. I’ve had two main issues with Touch ID. The first revolves around scanning the fingerprints. Sometimes when clicking my Home button, I use the very tips of my fingers rather than the larger area where you main fingerprint is found. So unlocking the phone will not work for me with Touch ID in those cases. Perhaps I could have done a better job positioning my finger during the setup process, but I feel that the system should have given me the opportunity to add “more of my finger” to individual fingerprint registrations. I easily solved this issue by registering the tip of my thumb as a new finger, but this takes up one of my five slots.

Trying to redeem promo code & log into iTunes account

Trying to redeem promo code & log into iTunes account on iPhone 5s

My second issue with Touch ID is all about making purchases from the App Store, iTunes Store, and iBookstore. It works, and it works well, for simply choosing an item and downloading it. But I am very surprised that Touch ID was not more fleshed out for tasks involving Apple’s stores. For example, signing into iTunes Radio and iTunes Match required inputting my full password. As did trying to redeem an app on the App Store with a promo code and other occasions in which Apple would pop-up the Apple ID login screen. Until those gaps are filled, Touch ID is not a password replacement for Apple’s iOS media stores.

iOS 7.0 for iPhone 5s shipped with a well-documented bug involving Touch ID not consistently appearing as an option for authenticating downloads. I have not seen this issue while running the already-available iOS 7.0.1 update.

I feel that Touch ID could be even more attached to payments, such as in the Apple Store app and third-party apps, and Tim Cook seems to agree. There’s been a lot of talk about Touch ID, Apple storing your fingerprints, and security factors. I’ve disregarded all of that and I think it is a non-issue. Apple says that it does not store your fingerprints on its servers, and I have no reason to not believe that.

IMG_4061

Conclusion: The iPhone 5s seems to be a great update for anyone upgrading from an iPhone 4s or older, for those getting their first smartphone, or for customers wanting to try out a different platform. For those moving from an iPhone 5, it is a bit of a tougher sell, but the promise of Touch ID and the future of 64-bit apps could be worth the excitement for some iPhone 5 users.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

28 Responses to “Review: 24 hours with the iPhone 5s…”

  1. Nice review. I’ll be upgrading from a 4S.

    Still waiting to get my, “Your iPhone has Shipped,” email. I have a gold 32GB showing 1-3 business days on the Apple website. If I could fast forward a week, I would.

  2. rogifan says:

    Can someone explain why the 5S is supposed to appeal to someone who owns a 5? Outside of tech geeks how many people really buy a new phone every year?

    • rettun1 says:

      I convinced an acquaintance of mine to let me use their upgrade and they get my iPhone 5. Plus with all the new carrier services rolling out (Jump, Next, etc), I’m sure more and more people will upgrade yearly

    • mockery17 says:

      I am one of the people who upgraded to the 5s from a 5. I upgraded because of Touch ID and support for more LTE bands. I genuinely think Touch ID is huge, and I already feel typing passwords is slow and outdated.

    • Oliver Stamm says:

      It’s your very own decision. I will upgrade from my 5 to 5S mainly because of LTE available now which was not the case before. I’m on Vodafone DE network. Second reason is the color, I’m really looking forward to the space grey and third but not least the camera. I hoping for much nicer photos especially when shot in artificial light conditions. BTW the upgrade won’t cost you as much as you think. I can sell my 5 for roundabout €450. Still a notable €250 difference but….! Of course only if you have a unlocked version. Or I wait until my contract renews but I don’t know if I can hold off that long till February ;)

    • standardpull says:

      Most 5 owners still have a year left on their contract, so I think that most 5 owners will not move to a 5S. Those that do will see lots of general upgrades to the CPU, cell, and camera system, plus the new capabilities of the fingerprint system and motion processor. These new capabilities will be most useful when apps start to leverage them, likely starting in the next few weeks.

      And so I do think the 5S will become even more compelling than the 5 with time.

      For owners no longer under contract, mainly those with any device older than 2 years old, the 5S seems exceedingly compelling versus any other device on the market.

  3. lycius84 says:

    Very nice review. I upgraded from a two year old 16 GB 4S which was still performing beautifully. Managed to get $200 off AT&T and got me a Space Gray 64GB 5s.

    The speeds are very noticeable, having LTE now (which was just implemented in my area month or so ago) is an unexpected feature I also enjoy. All in all, happy with my upgrade after 24 hours.

  4. Good review, but what does “off of” mean? You use it in so many different ways and it is very jarring and confusing.

    • Awe Wyld says:

      To be fair, the article uses ‘off of’ once and ‘off’ twice: “…customers coming off of an iPhone 5″ and “…turning off and turning on the phones”. In both examples the meaning is contextual and self-evident. Not exactly “in so many different ways”, nor “very jarring and confusing”. Although the ‘of’ in the phrase ‘off of’ is considered redundant in British English, it is a common informal idiom in American English.

      Also to be fair, ‘off’ has many usages and meanings. It’s used as an adverb, preposition, adjective, transitive verb, noun, and abbreviation. The various meanings are too many to list here.

      There are numerous written precedents for ‘off of’. It’s in the Bible (I said, “In the cutting off of my days I shall go to the gates of the grave; I am deprived of the residue of my years”. – Isaiah 38:10). Shakespeare used it in Henry VI, Part II:

      Winchester: What, art thou lame?
      Simpcox: Ay, God Almighty help me!
      Earl of Suffolk: How camest thou so?
      Simpcox: A fall off of a tree.

      Samuel Pepys used it (“and there eat a bit of roast meat off of the spit”), as did Thomas Hobbes (“the throwing off of Air”) and John Bunyan (“Then said Mercy, There is a looking-glass hangs up in the dining-room, off of which I cannot take my mind” – The Pilgrim’s Progress). Elbert Hubbard used it in title of his slim volume ‘Who Lifted the Lid off of Hell?’.

      Barry Brummett uses it nine times (!) in the space of two pages in his book ‘A Rhetoric of Style’ (“read off of texts”, pg. 137-138).

      A favourite usage example is from Dorsey’s ‘Traditions of the Caddo’: “…and just as he let himself off of the limb it broke off and down came Opossum. Coyote was upon him and gave him a good beating, and then left him to die. Opposum fooled Coyote, for he was not hurt at all…”.

      More recently in Suzanne Collins’ ‘The Hunger Games’ Katniss attends to Peeta’s leg wound inflicted by Cato: “Trying to be as gentle as I can, I remove his boots, his socks, and then very slowly inch his pants off of him”, pg. 255-256.

      Then there are numerous song titles such as Lauren Hill’s ‘Can’t Take My Eyes Off Of You’ and The Rolling Stones ‘Get Off Of My Cloud’.

      Heck, if the the venerable OED can add ‘selfie’ and ‘twerking” I think we can relax about ‘off of’.

      Btw, nice review Mark!

  5. Do people still think that “calibrating” the battery is still necessary?

    • “Of course, this could change as the battery continues to calibrate, and I did attempt to calibrate my battery yesterday by running it down to 0% and charging it up fully.” — I guess Mark does not know that they actually do this at the factory before you get the device…heh.

  6. I enjoyed using my iPhone 5 a lot though my iPad 4 is on the top of the list and I think having an iPhone 5s will add joy to the equation. I think I will wait a little bit to settle down the rush and get iPhone 5s on Black Friday with iPad 5 after-which I will sell my 5 and 4.

  7. John Smith says:

    i have to upgrade, and so I did, wasnt looking for too much as it was the interim “S” model – BUT, and its a big BUT, Im beside myself with the slow speed, seriously, opening apps, emails messages, photos, tweets,calling, etc, etc, etc, just got excessively slower from ios6 – it may be an amazing processor, i dunno, but the amount of things i can accomplish in a day on my phone just got a whole lot less…i couldnt dream of Android, but here I am deliberating it…those apps and tasks spinging to life in what feels like slow motion is drving me mental…im so gutted

  8. romanko says:

    Thanks, Mark–very nice writeup. Congratulations to the new iPhone!
    Apple: Please, please shorten or remove those slow animations? It kills the whole iOS 7 upgrade and just feels wrong. Jony said good design is about the ‘inevitable’, well I don’t use my iPhone to admire animations; it’s my personal assitant and hardware is more than capable to provide instant response gratification.

  9. “but the promise of Touch ID and the future of 64-bit apps could be worth the excitement for some iPhone 5 users”

    I’d say it’s more like, the fact that there’s touch ID, the possibility of touch ID doing more for us in the future, and the promise there will be more 64-bit apps powerful enough to prove the A7 chip is a real advantage over the iPhone 5 – could be enough reason for upgrading. But let’s not forget the LTE bands, here in the Netherlands the iPhone 5 won’t be able to connect to some of our 4G networks.

  10. Chad Geiser says:

    Nice review Mark. I upgraded from the 5 to the 5S and the only reason I did is because I was able to get the phone by only having to pay tax, VZW gave me $300 for my iPhone 5 16GB so I was able to get the 5S 32GB for pretty much an even swap. I’m still trying to decide whether or not I want to get the new leather case because I have a silicon case that’s exactly the same (form and fit) so I don’t if paying $39 is really worth it, but it would be nice to have a case with the Apple logo on it ;)

  11. It’s called space grey because gunmetal grey is politically incorrect

  12. Making a iphone 5s review is bit hard

  13. I think it’s pretty lame the Apple case doesn’t work with the Apple OEM dock…

  14. Byron Swift says:

    I don’t know what you are doing right but my battery life sucks big time!!! Maybe I have to cycle the phone a couple of time but my battery has died twice since getting the phone Friday morning.

  15. PMZanetti says:

    Nice Review. But..

    “There’s been a lot of talk about Touch ID, Apple storing your fingerprints, and security factors. I’ve disregarded all of that and I think it is a non-issue. Apple says that it does not store your fingerprints on its servers, and I have no reason to not believe that.”

    Firstly, let’s just say it like it is, and “disregarded” means “ignored”.

    Second, you have no reason not to believe it? Mark, are you even slightly aware of what is going on in the world? Can you possibly believe Apple is completely omnipotent, and doesn’t fall under the sway of government and foreign bodies?

    I love Touch ID and will continue using it…. Fully aware that there is NO reason to believe that Apple doesn’t gladly hand over this data to the NSA for further databasing of all individuals. They’ve already got all your electronic communication and location data. Now they have a means of framing you for any crime in the world. Apple can lie through their teeth about this feature, with no fear of repercussion. Just as they lie about every other bit of data they funnel through to the mafia aka govnerment

    I’ve given up resisting these privacy invasions…but that doesn’t mean I pretend its not happening.

  16. Adrian Hull says:

    I have been using the 4s for close to 2 years. I find out from my cell phone provider that if I sign a 2 year plan I can get the 5s for $963!!!! What a bargain!!! A phone costing $963!!!! I think I will stick with the 4s. Things have gone way out of kilter.

  17. Speak is good quality? Are you kidding me? The 5s speaker is worse than my 4s, hands down. The 5s may be louder, but it is inferior in quality. They drive the 5s speakers past what they can handle (probably the same speakers as 4, but over driven). Podcasts with deep voices are un-listenable at max and near max volumes. I took it to the apple store, they acknowledged that my 4s sounded better than the 5s with podcasts (deep voices pop at high volumes, 4s at high volumes sounds crisp), said a new phone might be needed. Got the new iphone and it sounded the same. Guy said there was nothing he could do (i.e. design flaw)

  18. Worst phone I have ever bad,I phone has the worst customer service ,got I phone in February ,want keep charge,they want to pay for another phone