Safari 3.1 for Mac and PC released (Updated with review)

Wed, 03/19/2008 - 6:41am — Seth Weintraub
1412

Remember those super-fast WebKit specs we told you about a few weeks ago?  Remember how it was going to help Safari 3.1 become a much faster browser?  What about all of the other goodies?   Now you can get them in a final version of Safari.  Apple today unleashed Safari 3.1 using much more recent version of the WebKit engine.  Preliminary results (meaning going to all of our favorite sites) are quite good. 

It remains to be seen if speed increases like this (and iPhone/iPod touch) help Apple's browser gain marketshare

 

 

Review from Computerworld:

Apple released Safari 3.1

on March 18 with an updated rendering engine that makes the fastest Internet browser even faster.

On top of that, Apple's new browser includes some features that reflect the future of the HTML 5 specification: offline storage, media support, and CSS animations and Web fonts. It also adds some needed compatibility and bug fixes, as well as some other new features that really make it a great everyday browser.

For the uninitiated, Apple provides a great PDF overview of Safari. You can get the upgrade/installer from apple.com/safari/download/ (it's about a 16MB download for both Mac and PC) or simply update from Software Update. The installation is easy but strangely requires a restart on Macs but not on Windows. By the way, Safari 3.1 is the first Windows version not to carry the "beta" tag.

 

The interface and the user experience are largely unchanged from those in Safari 3.0. Under the hood, however, Apple has

made some significant changes

that it has pulled from the latest builds of the open-source

WebKit

engine.

WebKit is the framework version of the engine that's used by Safari. It is also the basis of the Web browsing engine in iPhone's Mobile Safari, Symbian's browser, the Google Android platform and Adobe's new AIR platform.

Testing

To check out how well Safari 3.1 handles Web sites, I ran it through some popular standards testing -- and found that it leads the pack. In the Acid3 Tests, which were created by the Web Standards Project to test dynamic browser capabilities, Safari 3.1 scored 75 out of 100, significantly higher than the previous version of Safari and other shipping browsers (Firefox 3 Beta 4 scored 68, while the most recent WebKit scored 92).

However, the big news is how fast the new version of Safari is. How fast? I tested Safari 3.1 on my first-generation 2-GHz MacBook Pro with 2GB of RAM. In MooTools' SlickSpeed speed/validity test, Safari came out on top in almost every category on both Mac and PC.

It also did significantly better than any shipping browser on the SunSpider JavaScript speed tests (although since these tests are hosted at WebKit.org, they are perhaps biased). For example, on the Mac, Safari scored 4430ms, compared with 5048ms for Firefox 3 Beta 4.

While I spend 90% of my time on a Macintosh, I also installed Safari on my Windows XP box to see how it stacked up against Internet Explorer, Opera and Firefox. In short, it worked extremely well for everyday browsing, offering speed and efficiency, especially on a four- or five-year-old machine. It also performed really well with lots of tabs open.

SlickSpeed Test

  Dojo
1.0.2
JQuery
1.2.3
MooTools
1.2 Beta 2
Prototype
1.6.0.2
Mac OS        
Safari 3.1 91 138 209 272
Firefox 3
Beta 2
142 235 151 282
Opera 9.25 225 431 426 562
Windows        
Safari 3.1 171 171 250 236
Firefox 2.0.12 286 439 267 398
IE7 335 468 869 1987
All measurements are in milliseconds. Lower numbers are better.

Although Safari 3.1 does perform much better than the shipping version of Firefox, the speed improvements in Firefox 3 Beta 4 are catching up with Safari 3.1 -- though Firefox 3 did consume more CPU cycles during my tests.

One of the drawbacks of Safari has been the perceived "over-smoothing" or softening of fonts on the PC. While this hasn't been completely fixed, Apple's Safari 3.1 allows Web sites to specify fonts outside the seven Web-safe font families; these new fonts can be downloaded by the browser as needed.

Unfortunately, there are still prominent features that are part of rival browsers that Safari simply can't match. For example, Safari doesn't have all of the add-ons that Firefox enjoys, such as the Google toolbar.

Furthermore, if you need to use a site that employs Microsoft's proprietary DirectX technology -- like Microsoft Exchange's Outlook Web Access, for example -- you'll find that the experience on Safari leaves much to be desired. In this case, you're better off using Internet Explorer.

Finally, Opera offers features, such as direct BitTorrent downloads, that aren't offered in Safari.

With the 3.1 release, Safari has become the fastest browser you can use. If that isn't enough reason to make a switch, its strong adherence to Web standards and rapid adoption of new technologies might make you think again.

( Filed Under: )

Comments

...and what does it break ?

116

As seems to be a recent habit of apple, I'm wondering what this update breaks.

- 10.4.9 broke my wifi (more than half a year later, wifi is still not stable like it used to)
- 10.5.2 broke dvd player in my powerbook
- airport firmware 7.2.1 breaks "normal" airport behaviour
- quicktime 7.4.1 breaks playback for many movies (sound, no image)
- itunes 7.6.1 breaks mp3 playback and movie playback...
...

everytime apple updates something, other stuff breaks. Reminds me of OS 8 days.

maybe your computer is just

76

maybe your computer is just knackered?

Re: What does it break?

74

Interesting that hardly anyone else has reported those breaks.

"hardly anyone" ? the apple

97

"hardly anyone" ? the apple boards are filled with those complaints....

been living under a rock ?

Help offered

102

Have you tried "repair permissions" within Disk Utility?

the apple boards would be

75

the apple boards would be filled with people that think things are broken, those that really know what's going on know how to fix it. just like how a mechanic would have customers with broken cars, you don't see people with cars that work just fine going to a mechanic and saying "no problems here" you're getting a totally biased POV, and lay off that other guy. everyone's cars break, some people just seem to be more 'accident-prone'... when really it's a USER ISSUE causing all of the problems. Mostly because they're morons, and for some others it's just normal wear and tear.

and still others are NOT dumb enough to just sit and complain and instead know to reformat and reinstall and POOF! no more issues.

quit complaining and acting like the whole world has these issues when most of the people out there DON'T.

Good good

55

Good good

 Ok nice update definitely

85

 Ok nice update definitely faster on Windows, but I'm running and English version of Windows XP SP2, but I am Dutch. I would like to change the language to Dutch, but it is not an option in the preferences panel. I guess Safari looks for the Windows version and changes it language to the same as Windows.

Does anyone have an idea how to change my browser to Dutch?

Thanks in advance!

Corrections

45

You mention:
sites like many corporate Microsoft Exchange’s Web Outlook also use Microsoft’s proprietary DirectX technology

You meant ActiveX, not DirectX

You say:
The Google Toolbar is the one add-on that sticks out but I have about five others that I would rather do without.

You mean that you would rather NOT do without.

Also, love to know which 5 firefox plugins you find so valuable.

Good review otherwise. Keep up the good work.

Apple rocks. This is the

56

Apple rocks. This is the best version of Safari ever! All those other browsers are jealous.

Google account

86

What surprises me is that since i run Safari on my PC (almost since the first beta) every time i try to log in to my Google-mail account Safari just crashes. It does it all the time. And i read nothing about it in your review... is this a personal bug ??

greetz nico

yeah it is a personal bug. 

87

yeah it is a personal bug.  Delete cache and maybe some prefs as well