Microsoft may be positioning its new $399 Surface Go tablet as a competitor to Apple’s $329 iPad, but I don’t think Apple need be particularly concerned.

On the, ah, surface, the Go looks like a good deal. For $70 more than the base-model iPad, you get something presenting itself as a full PC, running desktop apps rather than mobile ones. You can also add a $99 or $129 keyboard to turn it into a laptop, an option Apple reserves for the much more expensive iPad Pro.

Microsoft’s keyboards also include a trackpad, with the additional option of a $35 mouse …

But while all that sounds great, the reality is a little different.

First, while Apple’s base-model iPad is a very capable device, early reports suggest that the entry-level Surface Go really only exists to tempt people to take a look, before upselling them to a $649 purchase. The base model has a pretty weedy spec for something that has to run Windows 10 (even its S version). Upgrade to the more powerful model, and add the keyboard, and you’re looking at spending almost twice as much as the $329 iPad.

Second, ‘full PC’ isn’t necessarily a good thing: touchscreen tablets are not great devices for running Windows apps. Sure, it’s handy to have the option, but most of the time you’re going to want to use a trackpad or mouse. The iPad, in contrast, comes with an operating system and apps designed from the start to be used by touch. It’s going to be a much better user experience.

The reality is that, if you want a laptop, there are probably better options for the money. If you want a ‘laptop lite,’ then there are some very nice Chromebooks for less money. And if you want a full-on Windows laptop, then there are plenty of machines that make much more sense that this hybrid device. So personally I don’t think it’s a great option even for most Windows buyers.

That’s not to say I think it won’t sell. If you’re on a limited budget and trying to buy both a tablet and a Windows laptop, then the device just about gets you there for a reasonable price. It also offers cash-strapped buyers the option of laying out $399 now for a tablet that runs Windows, and adding the keyboard at a later date.

But if you want a tablet rather than a PC, the Surface Go doesn’t make much sense. Normally, I’d try to be even-handed and say that, if you want a tablet, you either want an iPad or a flagship Android model. But, honestly, there isn’t much serious Android competition these days, especially now Apple has addressed the main reason someone might have looked elsewhere: price.

So all Apple fanboyism aside, I’d honestly say: if you want a tablet, you want an iPad.

The Surface Go is no iPad killer – it’s not even an iPad bruiser. It’s a different kind of product aimed at a different kind of market. Will some people look at both before opting for the Go? Sure. But will it make any kind of serious dent in iPad sales? Not a chance.


Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news:

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.


Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news:

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and subscribe to our YouTube channel

About the Author

Ben Lovejoy's favorite gear