Poll: Should Apple abandon FineWoven iPhone 15 cases?

We all know the deal by now. Apple replaced its leather accessories with a new material it calls FineWoven. The idea is that getting out of the leather game at Apple’s scale lowers the company’s carbon footprint. So far, so good. But FineWoven hasn’t been a clear winner. Do you think the initial reaction has been overblown, or is FineWoven really as bad as its critics say?

Some of my favorite gear

Samsung Frame 4K TV (Save over 30%)

Enjoy powerful brightness and rich contrast with OLED HDR+. Discover pure blacks, bright whites and Pantone-validated color with OLED Technology. Starting at $1,299, save up to $1,900 for a limited time only!

For now, FineWoven is only available on select new products. This includes Apple’s MagSafe Wallet, AirTag Key Ring, Magnetic Link watch band, and Modern Buckle watch band. The biggest target for material haters is the line of iPhone 15 FineWoven MagSafe cases. The new cases retail for $59, same as leather, and come in five earthy colors. It’s also planet friendly, according to Apple:

Made from durable microtwill, the material has a soft, suedelike feel. The FineWoven material was also designed with the earth in mind — it’s made from 68 percent post-consumer recycled content and significantly reduces carbon emissions compared to leather. The case quickly snaps into place and fits snugly over your iPhone without adding bulk.

Apple does warn that using MagSafe accessories with the FineWoven case leaves what it calls slight imprints, but that seems to be the least of unhappy customers’ concerns. Personally, I’ve yet to experience the mystery that is Apple’s FineWoven material. I’m a case-free iPhone user since forever.

But if you prefer Apple’s premium cases over silicone, how has FineWoven treated you so far? Do you think we’ll see a revision to FineWoven cases at some point? Is FineWoven fine as is? How about FineWoven iPad covers?

Voice your view in our poll, and say more in the comments!

Some of my favorite gear

Samsung T7 Portable SSD (Save over 30%)

Compact design with massive capacity. With storage up to 4TB, save exactly what you need. Starting from just $95!

More

• Apple weaved itself into a fine mess with the awful iPhone 15 FineWoven case
• Apple’s FineWoven cases and bands come in these colors, plus all the other new accessories
• FineWoven iPhones case MagSafe marks
• Apple Watch Series 9 comes out Friday, still can’t buy Magnetic Link band [U]

Photos via our pal Parker Ortolani!

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.