Skip to main content

Class action seeks $2 billion over claims Apple Pay harmed UK consumers

Apple is once again under fire over how it operates Apple Pay, and whether that model is anticompetitive. Here are the details.

Campaigner says Apple Pay’s ‘hidden fees’ affected 98% of British consumers

As reported by The Guardian, a new £1.5 billion (roughly $2 billion) lawsuit brought by Fairer Finance founder James Daley claims that Apple’s control over Apple Pay limited competition, creating costs within the banking system that were then passed on to “the vast majority” of UK consumers, “regardless of whether they owned an iPhone”.

From the report:

It is the first UK legal challenge to the company’s conduct in relation to Apple Pay, and takes place months after regulators like the Competition and Markets Authority and the Payments Systems Regulator began scrutinising the tech industry’s digital wallet services.

The lawsuit alleges that Apple charges hidden fees through Apple Pay, contrasting it with Android, where it claims the same fees do not exist.

Here’s what Daley told The Guardian:

“By shutting out competition and charging hidden fees, Apple has pushed up costs for millions of consumers. Shockingly, this doesn’t just affect Apple Pay users or iPhone owners. Banks have passed these costs on to all customers, meaning everyone is paying the price.”

Apple, unsurprisingly, refutes Daley’s claims. In addition to calling the class action “misguided” and claiming it should be dismissed, the company issued the following statement to The Guardian:

“Apple Pay is a seamless and secure way for users to make contactless payments, and one of many payment options available to consumers. Apple does not charge fees to consumers or merchants for using Apple Pay, and banks see meaningful benefits from offering Apple Pay to their customers – most notably fraud reduction.”

Apple also highlighted recent platform changes, saying it has opened up near-field communication and secure element interfaces to third-party apps in markets including the UK, allowing them to support contactless payments.

Be it as it may, Daley’s lawsuit is now before the U.K.’s Competition Appeal Tribunal, where judges will assess whether it can go ahead.

Do you think Apple Pay harms consumers? Let us know in the comments.

Accessory deals on Amazon

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and subscribe to our YouTube channel

Comments

Author

Avatar for Marcus Mendes Marcus Mendes

Marcus Mendes is a Brazilian tech podcaster and journalist who has been closely following Apple since the mid-2000s.

He began covering Apple news in Brazilian media in 2012 and later broadened his focus to the wider tech industry, hosting a daily podcast for seven years.