Photo: USA Today

Photo: USA Today

Early overnight reports collated by Fortune unsurprisingly show analysts pleased by the higher-than-expected iPhone numbers, with five out of five rating the stock a buy, their price targets ranging from $75 to $252 above yesterday’s closing value. Apple reported iPhone sales of 43.7B against expectations of 38B, and revenue of $45.6B against the consensus estimate of $43.5B.

  • Katy Huberty, Morgen Stanley: Price target $630

  • Gene Munster, Piper Jaffray: Price target $640

  • Brian Marshall, ISI: Price target $600

  • Brian White, Cantor Fitzgerald: Price target $777

  • Peter Misek, Jefferies: Price target $625  …

Gene Munster wrote that emerging markets were driving the high iPhone sales.

The strength came from China up 28%, Brazil up 61%, Russia up 97%, Turkey 56%, and India 55% […] We estimate that iPhone unit growth would have been 11% excluding the impact of China Mobile launch which we believe added around 2 million units based on public reports.

Kate Huberty cited both Japan and China, noting that U.S. growth was also strong.

iPhone growth improved in a number of geographies, including double-digit growth in the US, 50% in Japan, and 28% in China.

Brian Marshall commented on the double-digit growth even with current products, and said that the larger iPhone 6 expected in September would represent the “mother lode.”

In our view, a large form-factor iPhone in 2H will spark a massive upgrade cycle (i.e., “mother lode”) in the ~280mil install base as well as the return of some former iPhone users from the Android platform.

Brian White glossed over his 36M iPhone sale estimate against the 43M reality, focusing on both the iPhone 6 and iWatch for the second half of the year.

In our view, more important than tonight’s results is the rollout of the iPhone 6 and entry into a new product category with the iWatch that we anticipate in the second-half of the year.

Peter Misek echoed the likely impact on shares of the iPhone 6 launch.

It is possible to be aggressively buying the shares ahead of what we believe will be a successful iPhone 6 launch.

AAPL stock climbed almost 8 percent in pre-market trading.

Screenshot 2014-04-24 07.15.10

Fortune also did its usual league table of the best and worst analyst estimates of Apple’s earnings, with The Braeburn Group’s Patrick Smellie taking top billing with an error rate of 3.4 percent, while Credit Suisse’s Kulbinder Garcha was in last place with a 12.7 percent error. The full table can be seen below, with Philip Elmer-DeWitt’s commentary worth a read.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

12 Responses to “Analysts respond to AAPL earnings, rating the stock a strong buy”

  1. tasteofapple says:

    It’s sort of funny and sad how fickle analysts are toward Apple… Every quarter they make tons of money by selling premium products, but the minute they fail to meet unrealistic and (usually made up) expectations, they are “doomed”.


    • How else do you get people to sell the stock, just before the reports come out (so you can buy it cheaper) and then watch as everyone who sold out tries to buy back their investments…

      Then you sell the investments at a higher rate, making money.


  2. @Ben, “and revenue of $45.6M against the consensus estimate of $43.5B”

    $45.6B…biggest single letter typo :P


  3. jrox16 says:

    Apple is doomed….

    = p


  4. David Imrie says:

    Apparently they also moved 7 times as many iphones as there are people in the world. 7 iphones per person!

    @Ben “Apple reported iPhone sales of 43.7B against expectations of 38M,”


  5. Hi Ben, one more typo: “Apple reported iPhone sales of 43.7B against expectations of 38M”

    …shouldn’t that be 38B?


  6. Well, I can safely state that I am not involved in these improved sales, because I do not have 300-500 USD for a phone that has a user interface, I cannot stand looking at.

    So I will stick to my iphone 3gs, with its iOS 6.