How badly do you want to believe? Badly enough to disregard the fact that it would take someone three seconds to fake a computer signature in an Adium log? Yes, we want to believe too, so there it is to your right. Remember, we outed the MacBook Air this way back in January of 2008. But those logs happened before the "Something is in the Air" signs were trotted out so it lent a bit of legitimacy to the whole thing.
Could Apple have made the same stupid mistake twice? Perhaps.