Earlier this year, Apple rolled out the ability to rate and review its own applications on the App Store, including built-in apps like Podcasts, Music, News, and Stocks. One thing that quickly became clear when this rolled out is that the Apple Podcasts is a polarizing app, with an average rating hovering around 2.0 stars.

This week, developer and App Store watchdog Kosta Eleftheriou spotted that the Apple Podcasts app had mysteriously jumped from a 1.8-star rating to 4.6 stars in just over a month’s time. Apple has since confirmed to The Verge that it is now prompting users to rate and review the Apple Podcasts application.

In a statement, Apple said that Apple Podcasts started prompting users to rate and review alongside the launch of iOS 15.1 last month. This is similar to how many third-party apps also prompt users to rate and review.

Apple confirmed to The Verge that it’s using a new prompt but claims it’s nothing out of the ordinary. “With iOS 15.1 released last month, Apple Podcasts began prompting listeners to leave a rating and review just like most third-party apps — using the standard Rating & Review prompt available to all developers,” a spokesperson tells us.

But as both The Verge and Eleftheriou note, there is an interesting trend to most of the recent (and positive) reviews for the Apple Podcasts app on the App Store. Many of the reviews are of podcasts themselves, not of the actual Apple Podcasts application.

The Verge compiled a list of some of the “Most Recent” reviews of the Apple Podcasts app:

  • “Amazing show! Hilarious and well researched,” writes SammyAls, adding, “The dynamic is amazing, and the content is SO needed! Love this.”
  • “Mobley has Depth and Insight,” writes xbacksideslider. “Nice to listen to thoughtful and factual podcast. Far from the superficial emotional appeals to envy and self congratulating faux empathy that so dominate popular culture.”
  • “The table,” says Jkimble6091. “Being a future young millionaire listening to Anthony Oneal keeps me on track during all the ups and downs of life.”
  • Ashlie and Anthony: “I’m so glad my friend introduced me to this podcast because now I’m hooked.”

Meanwhile, if you scroll down and look for the flood of 1-star reviews, many of them are focused on the Apple Podcasts app itself, with criticisms on the design, syncing features, and more. As The Verge points out, this is not a common occurrence with other podcast applications on the App Store. For apps like Overcast and PocketCasts, most reviews are for the apps themselves.

So what remains unclear is what’s causing this confusion for people rating and reviewing the Apple Podcasts app.

But intentional or not, standard or not, the problem with star scores is there’s no way to tell whether they’re legitimate. We don’t know if someone pressed a five-star button because they loved the app, or thought they were rating the podcast itself, or just wanted to close the prompt as quickly as possible. We don’t know if Apple is prompting everyone, or just its most dedicated fans, or some other algorithmic subset that just happened to give it an advantage.

Regardless of what’s happening here, it’s benefiting Apple and the Apple Podcasts app, which now has a glowing 4.7-star rating. Have you seen the new rating and review prompt in the Apple Podcasts app? Let us know down in the comments.

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news:

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and subscribe to our YouTube channel

About the Author

Chance Miller

Chance is an editor for the entire 9to5 network and covers the latest Apple news for 9to5Mac.

Tips, questions, typos to chance@9to5mac.com